launchpad development|
Size: 2902
Comment:
|
Size: 7740
Comment: Added more questions.
|
| Deletions are marked like this. | Additions are marked like this. |
| Line 2: | Line 2: |
| = A typical manual build of the a branch = | = A typical manual branch build use-case = |
| Line 6: | Line 6: |
| == Initiating the build for the first time == | '''Note''': the following mockups do not try to fit the current implementation of bzr builder recipes or the corresponding current LP models. == Initiating a build with an existing recipe == While viewing his branch, Guilherme: 1. Clicks on the "Build this branch" link, (MOCKUP REQUIRED) 1. A "Build this branch to a PPA" overlay appears displaying a selection for his target PPA and someone elses recipe that has been created to build toggle branches (shown below). Guilherme selects his target PPA where he wants the package to be published. By default, the recipe selector is displaying "toggle_std_pkging for Lucid by Toggle Dev Team" and the displayed recipe description states "This is the default recipe for building Toggle. It merges the official packaging branch only.". Guilherme realises that it's exactly what he wants and simply clicks "Build now". [[http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/build_now_overlay_v2.png|{{http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/build_now_overlay_v2.png|Build now overlay}}]] 1.#3 The overlay disappears and the branch page is updated with a "Recent builds" portlet listing the new build and its status, linking to (somewhere appropriate within) the PPA. == Initiating a build requiring a new recipe == |
| Line 9: | Line 18: |
| [[http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/build_now_overlay.png|{{http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/build_now_overlay.png|Build now overlay|width=1000}}]] 1. clicks on the "Build now" button (or "Create a build" or "Build this"), 1. An overlay appears displaying a template recipe to be used as there are not yet any recipes associated with this branch (image on the right). If there were already recipes available for this branch, Guilherme would have the option of simply selecting one (image on the left) or clicking on 'Create new recipe' which would expand the Recipe details and make the relevant fields editable as shown (image on the right). After checking the packaging branch and selecting the appropriate PPA and clicking 'Start build', 1. The branch page is updated with a "Recent builds" portlet listing the new build and its status, linking to (somewhere appropriate within) the PPA. |
1. Clicks on the "Build this branch" link, (MOCKUP REQUIRED), 1. A "Build this branch to a PPA" overlay appears displaying a selection for his target PPA and someone elses recipe that has been created to build toggle branches (shown below). Guilherme selects his target PPA where he wants the package to be published, and then reads the recipe description and realises straight away that it's not what he wants. He clicks on the recipe selector and selects the only other option. He reads the description of this second recipe, realises it's also not something he can re-user, and so clicks on the "Create a new recipe" link. [[http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/build_now_overlay_v2.png|{{http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/build_now_overlay_v2.png|Build now overlay}}]] 1.#3 The overlay transitions (fade in/out) to a "Create a build recipe for Toggle" overlay (shown below). Guilherme enters a useful name and description for his new recipe, selects his packaging branch and clicks save. [[http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/create_recipe_v2-collapsed.png|{{http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/create_recipe_v2-collapsed.png|Create recipe}}]] 1.#4 The overlay transitions back to the previous "Build this branch to a PPA" dialog, with his new recipe already selected. Guilherme clicks 'Build now'. 1. The overlay disappears and the branch page is updated with a "Recent builds" portlet listing the new build and its status, linking to (somewhere appropriate within) the PPA. |
| Line 14: | Line 26: |
| At this point, Launchpad will have created both a new recipe for Guilherme and the first build of that recipe. | == Initiating a build for a specific branch version or target distro series == |
| Line 16: | Line 28: |
| == Determining the state of the current build == | A week later, Guilherme needs to create and publish a specific version of his branch into a separate PPA. While viewing his branch, Guilherme: 1. Clicks on the "Build this branch" link, (MOCKUP REQUIRED) 1. A "Build this branch to a PPA" overlay appears displaying a selection for his target PPA and someone elses recipe that has been created to build toggle branches (shown below). Guilherme selects his target PPA where he wants the package to be published. By default, the recipe selector is displaying "toggle_std_pkging for Lucid by Toggle Dev Team" and the displayed recipe description states "This is the default recipe for building Toggle. It merges the official packaging branch only.". Guilherme realises that it's exactly what he wants - but he'd like to select a specific version of his branch, so he clicks on the "Build options" expander: [[http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/build_now_overlay_v2-expanded.png|{{http://people.canonical.com/~michaeln/bfb/build_now_overlay_v2-expanded.png|Build now overlay}}]] 1.#3 Guilherme selects the specific revision that he needs, and clicks "Build now" |
| Line 18: | Line 34: |
| A few minutes later, Guilherme decides to check on how his build of his branch is progressing... | = Determining the state of the current build = |
| Line 20: | Line 36: |
| == Re-using the recipe for a subsequent build == A week later, Guilherme needs to create and publish a specific version of his branch into a separate PPA... |
A few minutes after having created a new build, Guilherme decides to check on how his build of his branch is progressing... |
| Line 25: | Line 39: |
| NOTE: the following non-js mockups are out of date. | |
| Line 37: | Line 51: |
= See also = * [[BuildBranchToArchiveUI/UseCaseDailyBuild]] = Unresolved questions = * Regarding the build options: does it make sense to have a branch revision *and* Build daily as an option at the same time? * ''It is conceivably possible that someone might want a daily build of a fixed base-branch revision because the merged feature branch or packaging branch etc. is what is being tested, but I've no idea whether this is realistic. If not (or even if so) we can simply warn the user when they click Build daily if they have selected a version.'' * Julian asks: would we want to ensure that users can actually choose the daily build time for a daily build? (ie. it may be desired that the build happens at 3am local time for a group so the next morning they all get the update?) * Julian asks: Initially we may not even want the 'Build daily' option to be available to general users (due to resources), instead enabling daily builds via a separate interface? * ''We could ensure on this interface that it is only present/valid for certain groups etc. too?'' Mockups that are missing, maybe: * A page for a build * Failed * Successful * How does it use the manifest? * A page for a daily build (is this the same as the page for a recipe) * Most recent builds * When building next? * Stop building this for now / resume * What has changed on the branches since the most recent build? Unaddressed use-cases: * As a gnome-do enthusiast, I want to install the daily build for "gnome-do" so I can use the latest crack. * ''I think the question here is how do I *find* the gnome-do daily PPA right?'' * Should we have a page that represents a recipe? If so what would it be for & what would it look like? * ''Definitely - I mean, we want people to be able to edit the recipe. I assume it would look very similar to the recipe creation overlay above, but include more auxiliary info like builds that have been done with the recipe etc.'' |
A typical manual branch build use-case
Guilherme has his own branch of the Toggle project and would like to build and publish the resulting package in his PPA, using his own version of the official packaging branch.
Note: the following mockups do not try to fit the current implementation of bzr builder recipes or the corresponding current LP models.
Initiating a build with an existing recipe
While viewing his branch, Guilherme:
- Clicks on the "Build this branch" link, (MOCKUP REQUIRED)
- A "Build this branch to a PPA" overlay appears displaying a selection for his target PPA and someone elses recipe that has been created to build toggle branches (shown below). Guilherme selects his target PPA where he wants the package to be published. By default, the recipe selector is displaying "toggle_std_pkging for Lucid by Toggle Dev Team" and the displayed recipe description states "This is the default recipe for building Toggle. It merges the official packaging branch only.". Guilherme realises that it's exactly what he wants and simply clicks "Build now".
- The overlay disappears and the branch page is updated with a "Recent builds" portlet listing the new build and its status, linking to (somewhere appropriate within) the PPA.
Initiating a build requiring a new recipe
While viewing his branch page, Guilherme:
- Clicks on the "Build this branch" link, (MOCKUP REQUIRED),
- A "Build this branch to a PPA" overlay appears displaying a selection for his target PPA and someone elses recipe that has been created to build toggle branches (shown below). Guilherme selects his target PPA where he wants the package to be published, and then reads the recipe description and realises straight away that it's not what he wants. He clicks on the recipe selector and selects the only other option. He reads the description of this second recipe, realises it's also not something he can re-user, and so clicks on the "Create a new recipe" link.
- The overlay transitions (fade in/out) to a "Create a build recipe for Toggle" overlay (shown below). Guilherme enters a useful name and description for his new recipe, selects his packaging branch and clicks save.
- The overlay transitions back to the previous "Build this branch to a PPA" dialog, with his new recipe already selected. Guilherme clicks 'Build now'.
- The overlay disappears and the branch page is updated with a "Recent builds" portlet listing the new build and its status, linking to (somewhere appropriate within) the PPA.
Initiating a build for a specific branch version or target distro series
A week later, Guilherme needs to create and publish a specific version of his branch into a separate PPA. While viewing his branch, Guilherme:
- Clicks on the "Build this branch" link, (MOCKUP REQUIRED)
- A "Build this branch to a PPA" overlay appears displaying a selection for his target PPA and someone elses recipe that has been created to build toggle branches (shown below). Guilherme selects his target PPA where he wants the package to be published. By default, the recipe selector is displaying "toggle_std_pkging for Lucid by Toggle Dev Team" and the displayed recipe description states "This is the default recipe for building Toggle. It merges the official packaging branch only.". Guilherme realises that it's exactly what he wants - but he'd like to select a specific version of his branch, so he clicks on the "Build options" expander:
- Guilherme selects the specific revision that he needs, and clicks "Build now"
Determining the state of the current build
A few minutes after having created a new build, Guilherme decides to check on how his build of his branch is progressing...
Notes for graceful degradation - Non-JS version
NOTE: the following non-js mockups are out of date. Without JavaScript, the "Build now" link would go to a "/+buildbranch" page for the branch:
allowing Guilherme to select a recipe and indicate the ppa. If there weren't any recipes, or he wanted to create a new one, he can click on 'create a new recipe' which takes him to:
Once Guilherme successfully creates a new recipe he is redirected back to the +build page above.
Actually, an alternative here (given that it is all for the non-JS version) would be to combine the two pages into one (nope, that ui is getting too complicated, and it's just for the non-js version, better to keep it as two simpler pages).
See also
Unresolved questions
- Regarding the build options: does it make sense to have a branch revision *and* Build daily as an option at the same time?
It is conceivably possible that someone might want a daily build of a fixed base-branch revision because the merged feature branch or packaging branch etc. is what is being tested, but I've no idea whether this is realistic. If not (or even if so) we can simply warn the user when they click Build daily if they have selected a version.
- Julian asks: would we want to ensure that users can actually choose the daily build time for a daily build? (ie. it may be desired that the build happens at 3am local time for a group so the next morning they all get the update?)
- Julian asks: Initially we may not even want the 'Build daily' option to be available to general users (due to resources), instead enabling daily builds via a separate interface?
We could ensure on this interface that it is only present/valid for certain groups etc. too?
Mockups that are missing, maybe:
- A page for a build
- Failed
- Successful
- How does it use the manifest?
- A page for a daily build (is this the same as the page for a recipe)
- Most recent builds
- When building next?
- Stop building this for now / resume
- What has changed on the branches since the most recent build?
Unaddressed use-cases:
- As a gnome-do enthusiast, I want to install the daily build for "gnome-do" so I can use the latest crack.
I think the question here is how do I *find* the gnome-do daily PPA right?
Should we have a page that represents a recipe? If so what would it be for & what would it look like?
Definitely - I mean, we want people to be able to edit the recipe. I assume it would look very similar to the recipe creation overlay above, but include more auxiliary info like builds that have been done with the recipe etc.
