Diff for "VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/Inputs"

Not logged in - Log In / Register
Differences between revisions 1 and 21 (spanning 20 versions)
⇤ ← Revision 1 as of 2009-01-06 13:03:12 →
Size: 6196
Editor: julian-edwards
Comment:
← Revision 21 as of 2009-01-22 10:10:16 → ⇥
Size: 8942
Editor: julian-edwards
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 3: Line 3:
= Suggested new features = = Proposed new priorities =

Individual Priorities (1 highest) are listed in the columns, otherwise the **list is sorted in overall priority order** after review.
|| * || M || T || U || Feature || Story Points || Released ||
|| || || || || **Support for pocket dependencies in PPA**\\(proper fix for security dependency model)\\ https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/249860 || 8 || 2.1.11 ||
|| || || || || **API to copy packages**, particularly from the main archive to a PPA, but can be generalised. (bug 276022) || 5 || 2.1.11 ||
|| || || || 6 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#rebuild-archives|Rebuild integration and UI]]**\\Associated with Archive Branches || 8 ||
|| || || || 2 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#signed-ppas|Signed PPAs]]**\\See https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/125103 || 13 || 2.1.12 ||
|| || || || 1 || **Soyuz ACL manipulation API/tool**\\Allows ACL manipulation of packages (versus teams) via a distro tool || 8 || 2.1.10 ||
|| || || || || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#build-dep-ui|UI for build dependency work]]** to allow user-setting of the build dependency components/pockets || 5 || 2.1.12 ||
|| || || ||18 || **Multiple PPAs per person** || 5 ||
|| || || || || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#ppa-api|API manipulation of PPAs (bug 276020)]] || 13 ||
|| || || || || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#p3a-tokens|Complete Private PPAs]]**\\Management of passwords/security to access P3As || 20 ||
||NEW || || || || **Upload handling (ACLs etc) changes for the [[https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ArchiveReorganisation|Archive Reorganisation]]** || ||
||NEW || || || || **Deal with loss of components with the [[https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ArchiveReorganisation|Archive Reorganisation]]** || ||
||NEW || || || || **Deal with loss of components maintenance and support tracking [[https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ArchiveReorganisation|Archive Reorganisation]]** || ||
|| || || || || ** Support for handling [[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#debug-syms-in-virtual-buildds|debug symbol uploads in virtual buildds]]**\\(https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/156575) || 8 ||
|| || || || 4 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#unembargo-api|API/UI to unembargo security package]]**\\Model through the existing package upload table || 8 ||
|| || || || 15 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#soyuz-distribution-script|Re-write cron.publish in Python]] Spec: [[SoyuzDistributionScript]]** || 3 ||
|| || || || 7 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#package-sync-reviews|Provide support for package sync reviews]]**\\Consider how critical uploads, bugs, the upload queue and PPAs can interact || 13 ||
|| || || || 2 || **Package sets**\\See https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ArchiveReorganisation || ||
|| || || || - || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#licensing-metadata|Licensing Metadata support]]** (see [[http://wiki.debian.org/Proposals/CopyrightFormat|1]] and [[http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Packaging/LicensingGuidelines#License:_field|2]]\\ Extra data on SPR that specifies the set of licenses for a package; obtained by parsing the licensing description and creating a set) || 2 ||
|| || || || 8 || **Changelog repackaging for native source syncing**\\Allows us to store proper changelogs for Debian-NSS'd packages || ||
|| || || || 8 || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/55795|55795]], [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/139162|139162]], [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/247456|247456]] Fix changelog attribution and repackaging for native source syncing || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#changelogs|5]]** ||
||NEW || || || 9 || [[https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/214612|214612]] Support PDiff for apt-get update || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#pdiff|XXX]]** ||
||NEW || || || 10 || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/285207|285207]] Pool buildds between PPAs and the distro || **[[VersionThreeDot0/Soyuz/StoryCards#pool-builders|3]]** ||
||NEW || || || 11 || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/285206|285206]] Make buildmaster work with buildds that build any arch || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#any-arch-builder|13]]** ||
||NEW|| || || 12 || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/259422|259422]] Display PPA diffs against Ubuntu || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#ppa-diffs-ubuntu|5]]** ||
||NEW|| || || 13 || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/235064|235064]] Multi-series support in package uploads || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#multi-series-upload|8]]** ||
||NEW|| || || 14 || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/285205|285205]] Handle ddebs in Soyuz || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#ddebs|8]]** ||
||NEW|| || || 16 || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/280958|280958]] Show PPAs containing the same package on Ubuntu package pages. || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#show-ppa-packages|5]]** ||
||NEW|| || || 17 || Do an emergent "heat" on PPA's, which would quietly factor in downloads, subscribers, karma of uploaders etc. || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#ppa-heat|5]]** ||
|| || || ||19 || **SFTP package uploads**\\Provide a secure upload mechanism with synchronous feedback to uploaders; GPG still a requirement || 5 ||
|| || || || - || **Per-package apt:// download links.** || ||
|| || || ||20 || **NoMoreAptFtpArchive** (package metadata, speeds up publishing by ~20m) || 8 ||
|| || || || - || **PPA download counters**\\Enable the distro team to prioritise merges from PPA's based on real usage and popularity and testing\\Could depend on diskless archives, or could be done through log scraping || 3 (with diskless archives) ||
|| || || ||13 || **RealDistroReleases** (point-releases)\\Depends on 'Archive Branches' || ||
|| || || || - || **Archive from librarian** (dynamic pool, and autogenerated dists) || 20 ||
|| || || ||21 || **Archive Branches, Snapshot Archives and Independent Suites**\\(could we have hardy-intel?)\\If done with ''Diskless Archives'' makes archive branching cheap || 13 ||
|| || || || - || **[[https://blueprints.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+spec/upload-rss-feed|Upload RSS feed]]** || ||
|| || || || - || **LiveFS generation** || ||
|| || || || || **Begin with NoMoreSourcePackages** (https://edge.launchpad.net/bzr-builddeb, data model, branch uploads) || ||
|| || || ||22 || **Modelling seeds**\\Data model and basic germinate interface\\Could be done with 'NoMoreAptFtpArchive' which needs to know about seeds || 6 ||
|| || || || || **Package copying only shows first 20 packages (bug 276019)** || ||
|| || - || || || **[[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/236922|Current SourcePackage metadata persistence]]**\\Internal-only, performance and correctness, enables per-package features || 5 ||
|| || || || || Hang BPPH off SPPH || XXX ||
|| || - || || || **[[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/236925|Explicit Distribution.currentseries]]**\\Internal-only, perf and correctness || ||


= Bugs that we want to address =
|| * || M || T || U || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/55288|Bug 55288]] and [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/45270|bug 45270]]. Fix the publisher configuration system; get rid of the Lucille config stuff and prevent the publisher from failing when a new series is opened but is not initialised. Also see the [[https://blueprints.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+spec/remove-lucilleconfig|blueprint]] ||

= Other unscored new features =
Line 7: Line 60:
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/293106|293106]] Support quilt package format || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/214612|214612]] Support PDiff for apt-get update || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/285205|285205]] Handle ddebs in Soyuz || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/285207|285207]] Pool buildds between PPAs and the distro || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/285206|285206]] Make buildmaster work with buildds that build any arch || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/259422|259422]] Display PPA diffs against Ubuntu || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/235064|235064]] Multi-series support in package uploads || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/55795|55795]], [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/139162|139162]], [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/247456|247456]] Fix changelog attribution || ||		 || || || || || Sex up the /+builds pages with AJAX: Allow in-place re-try (including multiple arches), make failures more obvious, in-place rescoring, filter on series/arch/status. Will be discussed at the Soyuz UI sprint in February. || ||
|| || || || || Add AJAX to the +queue page: approve all, in-place approval, remove actions where not permissioned, possibly lots more usability optimisations. || ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/305331|305331]] Soyuz instant messenger buddy (XMPP). For notifications of important events like build failures. Probably not limited to Soyuz || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#xmpp|XXX]]** ||
|| || || || || [[https://edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+spec/soyuz-karma|Karma for uploads]] || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#karma|2]]** ||
|| || || || || [[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/179873|File bugs on PPA packages]] || ||
Line 17: Line 67:

= Current priorities for the Soyuz Team =
See [[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz]]

Priorities (1 highest)
|| * || M || T || U || Feature || Story Points || Released ||
|| || || || || **Support for pocket dependencies in PPA**\\(proper fix for security dependency model)\\ https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/249860 || 8 || 2.1.11 ||
|| || || || || **API to copy packages**, particularly from the main archive to a PPA, but can be generalised. (bug 276022) || 5 || 2.1.11 ||
||14.3|| 12|| || 6 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#rebuild-archives|Rebuild integration and UI]]**\\Associated with Archive Branches || 8 ||
|| 2.7|| 5 || 1 || 2 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#signed-ppas|Signed PPAs]]**\\See https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/125103 || 13 || 2.1.12 ||
||22.3|| 17|| || 1 || **Soyuz ACL manipulation API/tool**\\Allows ACL manipulation of packages (versus teams) via a distro tool || 8 || 2.1.10 ||
|| || || || || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#build-dep-ui|UI for build dependency work]]** to allow user-setting of the build dependency components/pockets || 5 || 2.1.12 ||
||15.0|| 10|| ||10 || **Multiple PPAs per person** || 5 ||
|| || || || || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#ppa-api|API manipulation of PPAs (bug 276020)]] || 13 ||
|| 8.3|| 14|| 4 || 7 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#package-sync-reviews|Provide support for package sync reviews]]**\\Consider how critical uploads, bugs, the upload queue and PPAs can interact || 13 ||
||10.3|| || || || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#p3a-tokens|Complete Private PPAs]]**\\Management of passwords/security to access P3As || 20 ||
|| || || || || ** Support for handling [[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#debug-syms-in-virtual-buildds|debug symbol uploads in virtual buildds]]**\\(https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/156575) || 8 ||
||13.3|| 11|| || 4 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#unembargo-api|API/UI to unembargo security package]]**\\Model through the existing package upload table || 8 ||
||19.7|| - || || 9 || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#soyuz-distribution-script|Re-write cron.publish in Python]] Spec: [[SoyuzDistributionScript]]** || 3 ||
||21.7|| 15|| || - || **[[VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/StoryCards#licensing-metadata|Licensing Metadata support]]** (see [[http://wiki.debian.org/Proposals/CopyrightFormat|1]] and [[http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Packaging/LicensingGuidelines#License:_field|2]]\\ Extra data on SPR that specifies the set of licenses for a package; obtained by parsing the licensing description and creating a set) || 2 ||
|| 8.0|| 13|| 3 || 8 || **Changelog repackaging for native source syncing**\\Allows us to store proper changelogs for Debian-NSS'd packages || ||
||15.3|| 6 || ||15 || **SFTP package uploads**\\Provide a secure upload mechanism with synchronous feedback to uploaders; GPG still a requirement || 5 ||
||25.0|| - || || - || **Per-package apt:// download links.** || ||
||15.3|| 9 || ||12 || **NoMoreAptFtpArchive** (package metadata, speeds up publishing by ~20m) || 8 ||
||18.0|| 4 || || - || **PPA download counters**\\Enable the distro team to prioritise merges from PPA's based on real usage and popularity and testing\\Could depend on diskless archives, or could be done through log scraping || 3 (with diskless archives) ||
||17.3|| - || || 2 || **Package sets**\\See https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ArchiveReorganisation || ||
||18.7|| 18|| ||13 || **RealDistroReleases** (point-releases)\\Depends on 'Archive Branches' || ||
||19.3|| 8 || || - || **Archive from librarian** (dynamic pool, and autogenerated dists) || 20 ||
||20.3|| - || ||11 || **Archive Branches, Snapshot Archives and Independent Suites**\\(could we have hardy-intel?)\\If done with ''Diskless Archives'' makes archive branching cheap || 13 ||
||22.0|| 16|| || - || **[[https://blueprints.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+spec/upload-rss-feed|Upload RSS feed]]** || ||
||25.0|| - || || - || **LiveFS generation** || ||
|| || 2 || 2 || || **Begin with NoMoreSourcePackages** (https://edge.launchpad.net/bzr-builddeb, data model, branch uploads) || ||
||21.3|| - || ||14 || **Modelling seeds**\\Data model and basic germinate interface\\Could be done with 'NoMoreAptFtpArchive' which needs to know about seeds || 6 ||
|| || || || || **Package copying only shows first 20 packages (bug 276019)** || ||
||25.0|| - || || || **[[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/236922|Current SourcePackage metadata persistence]]**\\Internal-only, performance and correctness, enables per-package features || 5 ||
|| || || || || Hang BPPH off SPPH || XXX ||
||25.0|| - || || || **[[https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/236925|Explicit Distribution.currentseries]]**\\Internal-only, perf and correctness || ||

Proposed new priorities

Individual Priorities (1 highest) are listed in the columns, otherwise the list is sorted in overall priority order after review.

* M T U Feature Story Points Released
Support for pocket dependencies in PPA
(proper fix for security dependency model)
https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/249860 		8 2.1.11
API to copy packages, particularly from the main archive to a PPA, but can be generalised. (bug 276022) 5 2.1.11
6 Rebuild integration and UI
Associated with Archive Branches 		8
2 Signed PPAs
See https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/soyuz/+bug/125103 		13 2.1.12
1 Soyuz ACL manipulation API/tool
Allows ACL manipulation of packages (versus teams) via a distro tool 		8 2.1.10
UI for build dependency work to allow user-setting of the build dependency components/pockets 5 2.1.12
18 Multiple PPAs per person 5
API manipulation of PPAs (bug 276020) 13
Complete Private PPAs
Management of passwords/security to access P3As 		20
NEW Upload handling (ACLs etc) changes for the Archive Reorganisation
NEW Deal with loss of components with the Archive Reorganisation
NEW Deal with loss of components maintenance and support tracking Archive Reorganisation
Support for handling debug symbol uploads in virtual buildds
(https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/156575) 		8
4 API/UI to unembargo security package
Model through the existing package upload table 		8
15 Re-write cron.publish in Python Spec: SoyuzDistributionScript 3
7 Provide support for package sync reviews
Consider how critical uploads, bugs, the upload queue and PPAs can interact 		13
2 Package sets
See https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ArchiveReorganisation
- Licensing Metadata support (see 1 and 2
Extra data on SPR that specifies the set of licenses for a package; obtained by parsing the licensing description and creating a set) 		2
8 Changelog repackaging for native source syncing
Allows us to store proper changelogs for Debian-NSS'd packages
8 55795, 139162, 247456 Fix changelog attribution and repackaging for native source syncing 5
NEW 9 214612 Support PDiff for apt-get update XXX
NEW 10 285207 Pool buildds between PPAs and the distro 3
NEW 11 285206 Make buildmaster work with buildds that build any arch 13
NEW 12 259422 Display PPA diffs against Ubuntu 5
NEW 13 235064 Multi-series support in package uploads 8
NEW 14 285205 Handle ddebs in Soyuz 8
NEW 16 280958 Show PPAs containing the same package on Ubuntu package pages. 5
NEW 17 Do an emergent "heat" on PPA's, which would quietly factor in downloads, subscribers, karma of uploaders etc. 5
19 SFTP package uploads
Provide a secure upload mechanism with synchronous feedback to uploaders; GPG still a requirement 		5
- Per-package apt:// download links.
20 NoMoreAptFtpArchive (package metadata, speeds up publishing by 20m) 8
- PPA download counters
Enable the distro team to prioritise merges from PPA's based on real usage and popularity and testing
Could depend on diskless archives, or could be done through log scraping 		3 (with diskless archives)
13 RealDistroReleases (point-releases)
Depends on 'Archive Branches'
- Archive from librarian (dynamic pool, and autogenerated dists) 20
21 Archive Branches, Snapshot Archives and Independent Suites
(could we have hardy-intel?)
If done with ''Diskless Archives'' makes archive branching cheap 		13
- Upload RSS feed
- LiveFS generation
Begin with NoMoreSourcePackages (https://edge.launchpad.net/bzr-builddeb, data model, branch uploads)
22 Modelling seeds
Data model and basic germinate interface
Could be done with 'NoMoreAptFtpArchive' which needs to know about seeds 		6
Package copying only shows first 20 packages (bug 276019)
- Current SourcePackage metadata persistence
Internal-only, performance and correctness, enables per-package features 		5
Hang BPPH off SPPH XXX
- Explicit Distribution.currentseries
Internal-only, perf and correctness

Bugs that we want to address

* M T U
Bug 55288 and bug 45270. Fix the publisher configuration system; get rid of the Lucille config stuff and prevent the publisher from failing when a new series is opened but is not initialised. Also see the blueprint

Other unscored new features

Priorities (1 highest):

* M T U Feature Story Points
Sex up the /+builds pages with AJAX: Allow in-place re-try (including multiple arches), make failures more obvious, in-place rescoring, filter on series/arch/status. Will be discussed at the Soyuz UI sprint in February.
Add AJAX to the +queue page: approve all, in-place approval, remove actions where not permissioned, possibly lots more usability optimisations.
305331 Soyuz instant messenger buddy (XMPP). For notifications of important events like build failures. Probably not limited to Soyuz XXX
Karma for uploads 2
File bugs on PPA packages
  • = overall, M = Mark, T = MOTU, U = Ubuntu

VersionThreeDotO/Soyuz/Inputs (last edited 2009-08-10 12:56:35 by julian-edwards)